Article

When everyone has the same AI, proprietary data becomes the advantage

October 2026
ON THIS PAGE

Register for the newsletter

By subscribing you consent to receiving communications and agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms and Conditions.

By Felipe Ochoa, CEO of IncQuery

For a long time, one of the most valuable skills in consulting was knowing how to find information others couldn’t. As a Bain consultant, I worked on many projects where finding one useful industry data point meant digging through obscure sources and going to great lengths to track down the one person who actually had the answer.

Bain lore includes a story about a team trying to estimate beer brewery market share in a country lacking reliable data. Getting creative, the team visited multiple bars and counted the individual bottle caps from their dumpsters to estimate the true shares. Whether the challenge involved tracking down a hard-to-find source, manually stitching together a dataset, or literally collecting and counting physical objects, creating an information advantage often required considerable ingenuity and effort.

Today, AI can surface much of that same information in minutes. This represents a major gain in productivity, but it also creates a new challenge: if you can find the information that quickly, so can everyone else. AI is commoditizing access to existing information. The competitive advantage is shifting from finding what is already known to generating evidence that does not exist yet.

Access to information is no longer the moat

Traditionally, information retrieval has formed a significant portion of knowledge work. Consultants searched through analyst reports, databases, filings, and trade publications, while experts extracted value simply by knowing information that wasn’t published.

I remember one consulting project where I needed to estimate growth in miles of train track with certain characteristics. Cobbling together that time series required scraping back issues of an obscure trade publication and manually fishing out individual data points from dozens of PDFs. It was painful work that took multiple days, but it was valuable for our team – and client – precisely because the information was not readily available anywhere else.

Today, a capable AI system could likely achieve the same result with just a couple of prompts from a consultant and some tokens to burn.

Generative AI is collapsing much of the knowledge work related to information retrieval and analysis. Teams can now identify relevant sources, synthesize public information, and understand unfamiliar markets far faster than before.

This is good for the consulting industry. But as information becomes easier to access, any competitive advantage based on this knowledge work is evaporating. Access to the internet is not a proprietary research strategy. If multiple firms are evaluating the same market using similar AI systems that can query the same public sources of information, they are losing any competitive edge.

Nonetheless, LLMs currently struggle with effective source criticism and reconciliation of conflicting data points. These are core consulting skills where AI lags human performance, but this is an analytical limitation, which future models may overcome. Said models will likely become better at comparing conflicting evidence, identifying inconsistencies, and discerning source quality; there are benchmarks for this already. Expect analysis and synthesis of secondary data to become less of a differentiated advantage over time.

The advantage is in the data you create

Many of the most important business questions cannot be answered by searching harder.

An investment team may want to know how customers would react to a price increase. A strategy team may need to understand what actually drives switching behavior. A consultant may need to quantify how purchasing criteria differ across customer segments.

AI can summarize what has already been recorded and help identify hypotheses. But it cannot retrieve an answer to a question that has never been explored. Someone has to create the data.

This is where proprietary primary research becomes more valuable. A survey or structured research program can generate information specific to the question at hand, producing findings that competitors cannot simply retrieve from the same public sources.

In this world, proprietary data becomes the source of your competitive advantage.

Better questions become more valuable

As information retrieval gets cheaper, knowing what to ask becomes even more important.

The higher-value work is identifying what remains uncertain after AI has synthesized everything that already exists. Which assumption is still untested? Where is the investment thesis relying on anecdotes instead of solid data? What evidence could actually change the decision?

AI can help formulate those questions, but deciding which uncertainties matter still requires judgment.

In that sense, AI does not reduce the need for primary research. It can make the need more obvious. Once everything that is already known has been summarized, the gaps become much easier to see.

Proprietary data matters even more in an agentic world

As organizations rely more heavily on AI agents to support analysis and decision-making, the advantage will be in the ability to supply the right data to these agents.

Give an agent the same public information available to every competitor, and there is little reason to expect a differentiated conclusion. Give the agent proprietary evidence about your customers, market, or investment target, and the calculation changes.

The advantage may not belong to the firm with the biggest team or even the best general-purpose AI model. It may belong to the firm that can continually supply its systems with better evidence.

From information advantage to evidence advantage

AI is making research dramatically faster, and this is a good thing. Consultants and investors should use these tools to synthesize existing information, accelerate analysis, and understand markets.

But speed alone will not give teams a durable advantage when everyone has access to similar tools.

The more capable AI becomes at finding, evaluating, and synthesizing what the world already knows, the more valuable it becomes to know something the world does not.

For years, the advantage belonged to the people who knew where to find the answer. Increasingly, it will belong to the people who know which new questions are worth answering, and can generate the data to answer them.

Latest articles

Articles

Value creation research for private equity and consulting: What can customers tell you?

Articles

What is response bias, and how can you reduce it? 

Articles

AI has commoditized research synthesis

Articles

PE firms need to kill bad deals faster

get in touch

See how IncQuery can  eliminate your lingering doubts

Explore IncQuery with an expert who can answer your questions, discuss your needs, and show you how it works in practice.

Request a demo